Tuesday, 4 February 2014
Tagxedo
Wordle
Jigzone Puzzle
Blog Three
Using Comics and Graphic Novels in the Classroom
Comic books have existed as a genre of children’s
literature for many years; however beliefs about their use within the classroom
remain of controversial debate, with many negative perspectives held
surrounding their effectiveness as an educational stimulus for learning. Additionally,
the use of and exposure of graphics novels, within the classroom, poses further
concern with parents and educators. Millard and Marsh (2001) reiterate this by
explaining that the combination of cartoon images and colloquial language
trouble some adults, who are concerned with the effect that children’s reading
choices have on their academic and social development. It is therefore
significant, that forms of such literature are closely explored, in which to
ensure they prove suitable material for use within the classroom. Stafford
(2009) reiterates this point, claiming that in order for comic books to pose
successful and valuable resources within the classroom, teachers need to establish
their suitability in regards to their age appropriateness. However, if
monitored accurately and considered appropriate, the use of comic books and
graphic novels can provide stimulating, engaging and creative contexts, where
pupils can develop learning within an enriched and extensive literacy
curriculum.
Jacob (2007) supports this and stresses the
importance of comic stripes as a highly supportive stimulus for literacy,
recommending that educators; ‘’see the potential that exists when teachers
engage with comics in a meaningful way’’. This asserts that the learning
experiences and opportunities made available to children through the use of comic
books and graphic novels, are invaluable and can be vitally influential to
learning, therefore they should seek to be made an accessible part of the
literacy curriculum. As pointed out by Stafford (2011); the use of comic books
can specifically aid sequencing skills and the teaching of direct and indirect
speech. Equally, it is clear that comics lend themselves as highly stimulating
focuses in the development of writing and comprehension.
Nevertheless, whilst the use of comic books and
graphic novels are believed to generate engaging, creative and exciting
learning opportunities, issues still centre on their influence and relevance surrounding
academic development. Specifically, the current under use of such reading
materials, appears in the resistance of teachers to recognize their educational
potential. As Burn & Durran (2007) acknowledge, it is possible that some
teachers simply do not possess a
schema that connects comic books, or graphic novels with learning. It may also
appear that teachers do not know enough about comic related research and image
as a literacy skill. Furthermore, they may simply hold a lack of knowledge,
interest or confidence when utilizing comics creatively within the curriculum. However
as (Kress, 1997) states, the move to new forms of visual literacy has formed a significant
part of current communication and curriculum learning, suggesting that the use
of comics could instead enhance learning development and engagement to inform
current initiatives and interests.
Again however, it is important to consider that
teachers have been taught to reflect the movement from pictures to words
largely as an intellectual progression (Millard & Marsh, 2001). This is an
important factor to consider and could support and provide reasoning into the limited
use of comics and graphic novels within the classroom. However a
thought-provoking discussion raised in the seminar challenged this view, and
considered that reading should not simply just be about written text, but all
factors forming a narrative, including the influence of image. It was discussed
that although children’s reading should seek to progress from basic texts, to
more complex forms of reading material, the use of image played a significant
role surrounding child’s reading interests, as well as to support academic
meaning, and therefore was considered an invaluable resource to utilise within
the primary classroom, not to be restricted but explored and embraced within
future classrooms.
Burn, A. & Durran, J. (2007) Media Literacy in Schools: Practice
Production and Progression. London: Paul Chapman.
Jacobs, D. (2007) Marvelling at the Main called
Nova: Comics as sponsors of Multimodal Literacy. College Composition and Communication, 59, 2, 180-205
Kress, G. (1997) Before
Writing: Rethinking the paths to Literacy. London: Routledge
Millard and Marsh (2001) 'Sending Minnie the Minx
Home: comics and reading choices' Cambridge
Journal of Education, 31:1, 25 - 38
Stafford, T (2009) ‘Teaching Comics’ in Duncan, D.
(2009) Teaching Children’s Literature:
Making stories work in the classroom Abingdon: Routledge
Stafford, T. (2011) Teaching Visual Literacy in the Primary Classroom. Oxon: David
Fulton
Sunday, 2 February 2014
Blog 3- The use of comics and graphic novels in the classroom.
Comics have often
received the most disapproval compared with other forms of popular culture and have
even received calls for censorship (Millard
and Marsh, 2001). Comics have been viewed by
some as enemies of reading due to the high pictorial content, which some
believe are less intellectually demanding, and possibly even damaging(Dean, 2010). The combination of cartoon images and colloquial language trouble some
adults who are concerned with the effect that children’s reading choices have
on their academic and social development (Millard and Marsh, 2001).
Whilst some
people may view comics and graphic novels as damaging to children’s development,
others see the potential that they can bring to children. Learning and
Teaching Scotland (Online) claim that comics and graphic novels provide opportunities
for learning, as they can encourage reading. Their format also allows complex stories to be
told in a simple and accessible way. Dean (2010) states that graphic
novels can support less enthusiastic readers, whilst challenging the stronger readers.
They are also invaluable to schools as they can help in supporting specific areas
within the curriculum and can also help to extend children’s leisure reading material.
Both comics and graphic novels enhance reading skills, rather than undermine
them (Learning and Teaching Scotland, Online), therefore, they should be used in classrooms as they foster opportunities for learning.
Schools and
library’s often approach comics and graphic novels with caution as some view
them as undermining literacy and due to their controversial content (Learning
and Teaching Scotland, Online). Therefore, it is important to monitor
their content, so that they are age appropriate (Stafford, 2009). This will help to change the negative views that
some hold, on their use within the school setting. It is important that parents and other skeptical
teachers are shown their diversity, and the range of reading experiences that comics
and graphic novels can offer (Learning
and Teaching Scotland, Online).
Overall comics
and graphic novels can be a great way to enthuse and engage children to both read
and learn. Whilst I have not seen or used comics or graphic novels in the
classroom, I would definitely use them in the future, due to their engaging
properties. I was particularly impressed with the graphic novels that I
explored in the seminar, which tackled difficult content such as Shakespeare. I
also purchased my first Beano for the seminar and was surprised at how much I
enjoyed reading it. As I found the comic enjoyable to read, due to its light
humour, I believe that children would enjoy reading them. Therefore I would
introduce them into my classroom in the future.
Bibliography:
Dean, G. (2010)
‘Rethinking Literacy’ in Bazalgette, C. (ed) Teaching Media in Primary
Classrooms London: Sage.
Learning and
Teaching Scotland: Graphic Novels in the Curriculum [Online]
http://www.educationscotland.gov.uk/resources/g/graphicnovels/intro.asp (Accessed: 28/01/14).
Millard and
Marsh (2001) 'Sending Minnie the Minx Home: comics and reading choices' Cambridge
Journal of Education, 31:1, pp.25 - 38.
Stafford, T
(2009) ‘Teaching Comics’ in Duncan, D. (2009) Teaching
Children’s Literature: Making stories work in the classroom Abingdon:
Routledge.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)